Meeting Votes

March 13, 2023 - March 16, 2023

Logistics Agenda Presentations Attendance Votes Notes
Registered: 34
OOE: 34
IMOVE: 31
Votes needed for individual vote quorum:

Individual organization's votes are show as colored blocks as follows:
Yes No Abstain

  1. Vote Topic: #154 (PR #762): New interface to query hardware resource info (no-no)
    Yes No Abstain Result
    31 0 0

  2. Vote Topic: #543 (PR #791): Pending operation not defined, pending proper definition (1st)
    Yes No Abstain Result
    30 0 1

  3. Vote Topic: #641 (PR #752): Including Annex A.2 back into the standard (2nd)
    Yes No Abstain Result
    29 0 2

  4. Vote Topic: #493 (PR #753): Issue N - Progress-Section in terms-2.tex (2nd)
    Yes No Abstain Result
    28 0 3

  5. Vote Topic: #471 (PR #751): Fix Incorrect Usage of Rank/Task/etc. in Terms Chapter (2nd)
    Yes No Abstain Result
    30 0 1

  6. Vote Topic: #565 (PR #727): Refer to Fortran 2018 instead of 2008+TS (2nd)
    Yes No Abstain Result
    29 0 2

  7. Vote Topic: #644 (PR #759): Update 'Process Topology' chapter title to use MPI process (2nd)
    Yes No Abstain Result
    30 0 1

  8. Vote Topic: #542 (PR #795): Correct usage of the terms error and return codes in the tools chapter (2nd)
    Yes No Abstain Result
    30 0 1

  9. Vote Topic: #414 (PR #723): Mention behavior with potential overflow (2nd)
    Yes No Abstain Result
    29 0 2

  10. Vote Topic: #564 (PR #800): Fortran Binding Issues and Capitalization (errata)
    Yes No Abstain Result
    29 0 2

  11. Vote Topic: #680 (PR #801): missing MPI_Scan_init and MPI_Exscan_init from a sentence on collective taxonomy (errata)
    Yes No Abstain Result
    30 0 1

  12. Vote Topic: #57 (PR #221): Deprecate MPI_HOST (no-no)
    Yes No Abstain Result
    31 0 0

  13. Vote Topic: #408 (PR #740): added reference to the fact that hints must be adhered to by the app (1st)
    Yes No Abstain Result
    30 0 1

  14. Vote Topic: #411 (PR #739): Fix comment on Info object in incomplete functions (no-no)
    Yes No Abstain Result
    31 0 0

  15. Vote Topic: #480 (PR #738): Fix Incorrect Usage of Rank/Task/etc. in External Interfaces Chapter (no-no)
    Yes No Abstain Result
    31 0 0

  16. Vote Topic: #541 (PR #647): Consistency Updates for MPI_Info Chapter for MPI 4.1 (1st)
    Yes No Abstain Result
    30 0 1

  17. Vote Topic: #555 (PR #671): Example 12.4, RMA communication calls may not block in PSCW (1st)
    Yes No Abstain Result
    29 0 2

  18. Vote Topic: #653 (PR #769): Make all RMA communication procedures local (no-no)
    Yes No Abstain Result
    30 0 1

  19. Vote Topic: #652 (PR #768): RMA, Examples 12.4 and 12.5 contain advice to implementors (no-no)
    Yes No Abstain Result
    30 0 1

  20. Vote Topic: #23 (PR #708): Allow MPI_WIN_SHARED_QUERY on created and allocated windows (no-no)
    Yes No Abstain Result
    30 0 1

  21. Vote Topic: #646 (PR #771): WTIME and WTICK should be symbols (2nd)
    Yes No Abstain Result
    29 1 1

  22. Vote Topic: #647 (PR #770): Handle conversions should be symbols (2nd)
    Yes No Abstain Result
    29 1 1

  23. Vote Topic: #561 (PR #722): Deprecate mpif.h (no-no)
    Yes No Abstain Result
    30 0 1

  24. Vote Topic: #538 (PR #761): Allow pset names to guide splitting in MPI_Comm_split_type (2nd)
    Yes No Abstain Result
    30 0 1

  25. Vote Topic: #117 (PR #748): Logically concurrent is not (2nd)
    Yes No Abstain Result
    29 1 1

  26. Vote Topic: #188 (PR #203): Section 3.5 - p. 45 - Comment Erroneous Example (2nd)
    Yes No Abstain Result
    30 0 1

  27. Vote Topic: #83 (PR #666): Info key for strict start ordering of persistent collective communication (2nd)
    Yes No Abstain Result
    30 0 1

  28. Vote Topic: #472 (PR #606): Fix Incorrect Usage of Rank/Task/etc. in Point to Point Chapter (2nd)
    Yes No Abstain Result
    29 0 2

  29. Vote Topic: #518 (PR #623): Deprecate all _x procedures (no-no)
    Yes No Abstain Result
    31 0 0

  30. Vote Topic: #683 (PR #810): Question: MPI_Dims_create - is 'as close to each other as possible' a requirement? (no-no)
    Yes No Abstain Result
    30 1 0

  31. Vote Topic: #341 (PR #806): RC issues found in chap-coll (no-no)
    Yes No Abstain Result
    31 0 0

  32. Vote Topic: #669 (PR #788): Add operation state enabled and local calls into Terms (no-no)
    Yes No Abstain Result
    30 0 1

  33. Vote Topic: #639 (PR #750): Clarification for the local/nonlocal nature of MPI_WAIT (no-no)
    Yes No Abstain Result
    30 0 1

  34. Vote Topic: #154 (PR #762): New interface to query hardware resource info (1st)
    Yes No Abstain Result
    28 1 2

  35. Vote Topic: #57 (PR #221): Deprecate MPI_HOST (1st)
    Yes No Abstain Result
    29 0 2

  36. Vote Topic: #411 (PR #739): Fix comment on Info object in incomplete functions (1st)
    Yes No Abstain Result
    29 0 2

  37. Vote Topic: #480 (PR #738): Fix Incorrect Usage of Rank/Task/etc. in External Interfaces Chapter (1st)
    Yes No Abstain Result
    30 0 1

  38. Vote Topic: #653 (PR #769): Make all RMA communication procedures local (1st)
    Yes No Abstain Result
    28 0 3

  39. Vote Topic: #652 (PR #768): RMA, Examples 12.4 and 12.5 contain advice to implementors (1st)
    Yes No Abstain Result
    29 0 2

  40. Vote Topic: #23 (PR #708): Allow MPI_WIN_SHARED_QUERY on created and allocated windows (1st)
    Yes No Abstain Result
    29 0 2

  41. Vote Topic: #561 (PR #722): Deprecate mpif.h (2nd)
    Yes No Abstain Result
    27 1 3

  42. Vote Topic: #518 (PR #623): Deprecate all _x procedures (1st)
    Yes No Abstain Result
    30 0 1

  43. Vote Topic: #520 (PR #798): Add compound datatypes for large integers for MPI_(MIN|MAX)LOC (no-no)
    Yes No Abstain Result
    30 0 1

  44. Vote Topic: #586 (PR #736): MPI_Buffer_attach and Sessions (no-no)
    Yes No Abstain Result
    29 0 2

  45. Vote Topic: #580 (PR #714): Memory Alloc Kind Info (no-no)
    Yes No Abstain Result
    30 0 1

  46. Vote Topic: #120 (PR #98): MPI_Cart_create_weighted, Topology aware Cartesian communicators (no-no)
    Yes No Abstain Result
    29 0 2